Holyrood bills face possible UK challenge
The UK Government has threatened to challenge provisions in two bills newly passed by the Scottish Parliament.
Scottish Secretary Alister Jack has written to Deputy First Minister John Swinney warning that the Scottish Government's United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (Incorporation) (Scotland) Bill, and Andy Wightman's member's bill to incorporate the European Charter of Local Self-Government, could affect the ability of the UK Government to legislate for Scotland and might be beyond Holyrood's competence.
Both bills were backed unanimously by MSPs after their final debates. The Scottish Government did not table amendments requested by Mr Jack to avoid a potential clash with UK legislation.
Mr Jack has four weeks from when each bill was passed by Holyrood to decide whether to refer it to the Supreme Court.
On the UNCRC Bill he wrote: "The UK Government has concerns with section 6 of the Bill relating to the legal obligations it could be seen to place on UK Government Ministers in reserved areas.
"This in turn means that the effect of the legislation may not be clear to citizens, stakeholders and those who may seek to use the legislation to test that relevant authorities are meeting their duties.
"The UK Government also has concerns with regards to sections 19-21 of the Bill. Our concern is that these sections of the Bill would affect the UK Parliament in its power to make laws for Scotland, which would be contrary to the devolution settlement (section 28(7) of the Scotland Act 1998)."
Similarly with Mr Wightman's bill, the Government "has concerns that sections 4 and 5 of this Bill... would also affect the power of the UK Parliament to make laws for Scotland, which would be contrary to the devolution settlement".
He continued: "I am aware that stakeholders in Scotland are keen to see that the UNCRC Bill is given royal assent as soon as possible.
"While the UK Government and Scottish Government have different views on the benefits of incorporating conventions into statute, as set out above we respect the Scottish Parliament’s ability to legislate on this in devolved areas.
"However, doubt about the competence of specific provisions in the bill serves no one."
Mr Jack added: "This need for clarity, not just for us, but for the children the UNCRC Bill is intended to protect and the stakeholders who represent them, is why I think it is essential that both governments respect the devolution settlement and we work collaboratively to resolve issues."